Did the Genie cheat Aladdin out of a wish?

lamp-308526_640Disney’s Aladdin. 

A classic of the Disney animated renaissance.  A star turn from the sadly missed Robin Williams, and probably my all-time favourite Disney soundtrack.  (You have another preference?  Let it go!)  So, when the stage version came to London, and my wife suggested we go, I leapt at the chance!  She regretted the suggestion soon after, as I spent the next month singing her the soundtrack, but, bygones.

Still, while I love it, I’ve always had a little problem with one plot point, and I was curious if the stage version would fix it.  Specifically:

Did the Genie cheat Aladdin out of a wish?

So, (spoilers) Aladdin meets the Genie, tricks him into rescuing him from the Cave of Wonders, and then asks for, and is granted, three wishes:

  1. “I wish for you to make me a prince!” 
  2. “…” 
  3. “I wish the genie to be free.”

The problem, for me, is that second wish, but possibly not in the way you’re thinking. 

In the movie, Aladdin is unconscious and drowning, so Genie bends the rules and accepts a gravity-fuelled nod as a wish.  Which, call me crazy, but that’s a little dodgy right there.  Benefit of the doubt though, in the stage show, Aladdin isn’t drowning or unconscious, he has been captured, so he directly and cleanly wishes for the Genie to free him.  Problem solved, right?

Well, no.  Because my problem is that in both cases Aladdin shouldn’t need to make that wish because the Genie is yet to complete granting the first wish, to make Aladdin a Prince.  And in either situation, Genie has an obligation to save Aladdin as part of granting the first wish.

 “Of course he made Aladdin a Prince!” you may respond, there was a whole song about ‘Prince Ali’,

what about all the lions, tigers, servants, flunkies and birds that warble on key?

It’s a great song!  But these are only the trappings of wealth, and are not necessarily qualifications for being a Prince.  And it’s a song about someone called Ali being a Prince, Aladdin is not, in any measurable way a Prince.  The first wish is yet to come true.

“Don’t be so literal!” you reply, and aren’t you being fussy?  But hey, don’t blame me, the Genie is literal.  When Jafar later wishes to ‘rule on high as Sultan’, Genie doesn’t just compose a catchy song about ‘Sultan Jaf’, he strips the clothes off the Sultan for Jafar and lifts the palace on top of a mountain so Jafar can literally rule ‘on high’.  Genie is all about the literal. 

So when Aladdin wishes to be made a Prince, it shouldn’t just be about the trappings of wealth, a false name and some fancy clothes.  Genie needs to literally make Aladdin a prince.

So, how would you “make a prince”?

Well I’m sure there’s all manner of socio-political definitions we could get into here, but to make Aladdin a Disney Prince, I think it only makes sense to look at the rules of being an official Disney Princess.  According to some excellent videos on the SuperCarlinBrothers YouTube channel (https://www.youtube.com/user/SuperCarlinBrothers) to be an officially recognised Disney Princess there are some pretty specific rules.

First, the character must be human, be the lead in an animated Disney movie, and not be primarily introduced in a sequel.   Second, the character must either be born royal, marry royalty, or perform an act of heroism.

Aladdin meets those first criteria without Genie’s help, so let’s look at the second.

Can the Genie make Aladdin be born royal?  Well, sure.  He has phenomenal cosmic power, and references things far in the future (or past, according to some theories I’ve seen), so time travel clearly isn’t a problem for Genie.  But if that was the route he took, then Jafar would have no influence on Aladdin’s princeliness and couldn’t simply sing it away with “His lies were too good to last”.

Can the Genie arrange for Aladdin to perform an act of heroism?  Again, definitely, but he doesn’t.  At any rate, not between the first and second wishes.  Throughout most of that time, Aladdin is acting pretty selfishly: singing, wooing and lying.  Nothing truly heroic in there, romantic lead, sure, but not heroic. 

Can Aladdin marry royalty?  He does!  And while the Genie doesn’t have the power to make people fall in love, he does go out of his way to help Aladdin with dating advice “Beeeeee yourself” to make that wedding happen. 

So, whether the Genie is making a Prince by arranging the heroism or marriage route (and we all know it’s by marriage, right?) then at the point of the so-called second wish, the first wish is still not complete, and cannot be completed if Aladdin dies, so the second wish is redundant!

The Genie only actually grants two wishes.  To make Aladdin a Prince.  And to set Genie free.

As Jafar would sing, it’s just a con!  Need I go on?

No.  No, I needn’t!

 

5 thoughts on “Did the Genie cheat Aladdin out of a wish?”

  1. Just watched the SuperCarlinBrothers channel on youtube present this theory. I agree that the second wish is a redundant because of the first still being incomplete, but here is where it might get a little confusing.

    Genie could of considered the first wish fulfilled when the Sultan announces that he is changing the law and Aladdin will marry his daughter. Granted at the time he is not a prince but will soon be with the marriage being announced.

    We can throw out the second “save me” wish, and claim that the setting Genie free was the second wish.

    The third wish which it seems you over looked. Before his celebration after Genie is “free” he tells Aladdin “to wish for something outrageous like the Nile say I want the Nile.” Which Aladdin does … but the Nile and denial are hard to distinguish outside of context. When Aladdin makes the wish Genie says yells “no way” and thus fulfills the third wish actually letting him be free.

    https://youtu.be/SUfP6IGQD00?t=32s

  2. (*Way* bending the fourth wall here.)

    Hmm – Aladdin asks to be “made a Prince”.. The Genie should have taken him *really* literally – Aladdin should have starting busting out Purple Rain or something!

    1. It’s a fun thought, but if we’re going with literal, that would be making him THE Prince. The definite article. He only wished to be A Prince. Thanks for reading!

  3. If I had three wishes I would only need 1 wish…it would be I WISH THAT I WOULD WIN EVERY BET WHETHER WITH MONEY OR VERBALLY….FOR EXAMPLE I BET YOU A DOLLAR THAT I WILL LIVE FOREVER…I BET THIS AND THAT AND SO FORTH… instead of saying I wish just say I bet and keep on going…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *